1. Contemporary Context: The “Non-Alcoholic” Wine Trend
While the heart of the theological question remains rooted in scripture and tradition, the wider beverage market is rapidly evolving — and that adds nuance to how Christians think about alcohol today.
Recent data show a surge in the so-called “non-alcoholic” wine and low-alcohol beverages sector. According to Real Simple, U.S. sales of non-alcoholic wine reached nearly $90 million in 2024, up 27 % from the prior year. However, the key caveat is that many of these “non-alcoholic” wines still contain up to 0.5% alcohol by volume (ABV), which may matter for those who aim to avoid alcohol completely.
Globally, analysis by the Wine & Spirit Education Trust (WSET) reports that beverages with ≤ 0.5% ABV are considered dealcoholised or non-intoxicating; full zero-alcohol (under ~0.04% ABV) remains a smaller but growing niche. In addition, there’s the regulatory and cultural dimension: In Italy, for example, the agricultural minister recently called for dropping the word “wine” from non-alcoholic products, highlighting concerns about tradition and meaning.
Why this matters theologically: If Christian consumption of wine hinges partly on what “wine” means (fermented, alcoholic grape-juice vs unfermented grape-juice), then what we call “wine” today and what people assumed in biblical times might differ significantly. It raises questions about interpretation, context and application.
2. What does Scripture say about drinking alcohol?
2.1 The first miracle: Turning water into wine
In the Gospel of John (2:1-11), Jesus attends a wedding in Cana of Galilee, where the hosts run out of wine. At his mother’s request, Jesus instructs servants to fill jars with water; he then transforms the water into wine.
What kind of “wine” was it? Some conservative interpreters argue it was unfermented grape-juice or very low alcohol, citing concerns that Jesus would not condone drunkenness. For instance, one article argues that the word “wine” (Greek oinos) in Scripture might refer either to juice or fermented wine, and “intoxicating wine” might not have been the creation of Jesus. Others point out that the steward at the wedding remarked that the wine Jesus provided was the “best” — implying qualitative richness and perhaps more potency than earlier wine served:
> “Everyone brings out the choice wine first … but you have kept the good wine until now.” (John 2:10 KJV)
From this text a few observations:
Wine (or grape-juice) was accepted in a celebratory context.
The miracle does not explicitly comment on the alcohol content, but does highlight joy, abundance and transformation.
Jesus did not appear to forbid wine in this scenario; rather, he provided wine.
The emphasis is not on intoxication but on overflow, abundance, blessing.
2.2 The Lord’s Supper / Holy Communion
In the New Testament, wine is used symbolically in the institution of the Lord’s Supper: Jesus takes the cup, gives thanks, and says “This is my blood…” (e.g., Matthew 26:27-29, Mark 14:23-25, Luke 22:17-20). By this act wine becomes a symbol of his blood, of covenant, of life poured out.
Historically, Christian churches have used fermented grape-wine for Communion. For instance the Church of England’s General Synod recently reaffirmed that “the wine must be the fermented juice of the grape” rather than “non-alcoholic wine” for the Eucharist to be properly consecrated. That ruling illustrates how doctrinal tradition still treats wine (with alcohol) as the norm in sacramental usage.
2.3 Warnings against drunkenness
Scripture is explicit in warning against excess. Ephesians 5:18: “Do not get drunk on wine, which leads to debauchery. Instead, be filled with the Spirit.” Proverbs 20:1: “Wine is a mocker and beer a brawler; whoever is led astray by them is not wise.” These passages make clear that over-indulgence or loss of self-control is what is considered sinful, rather than the mere consumption of wine or alcohol in and of itself.
Thus, a key biblical distinction emerges: It is not alcohol per se, but abuse of alcohol (i.e., drunkenness, intoxication, diminished self-control or harm to others) that Scripture opposes.
3. So-what: How do we apply this to the normal quantities question?
Given the biblical narrative and modern context, here is a reasoned framework for how to think about alcohol consumption, particularly for Christians:
1. Moderation and self-control: The biblical witness does not seem to condemn the consumption of wine in moderation; indeed, wine appears in celebrations, in the miracle of Cana, and in the Lord’s Supper. What is condemned is drunkenness, excess, and loss of reason.
2. Cultural and historical context matter: Wine in ancient Palestine was often diluted; water sanitation issues made fermented drinks safer; wine had lower ABV by modern standards. Therefore, applying ancient texts to modern high-proof alcohol requires nuance.
3. Intent and witness: Christians are called to consider how their behavior bears witness. Even moderate consumption may lead others into temptation, so “little of normal quantities” must be sensitive to context.
4. Symbolic integrity in sacrament: For Communion, many traditions hold that the wine must be fermented grape-juice (i.e., alcoholic) to maintain sacramental symbolism and continuity. That does not mean all Christian drinking must align with sacramental wine, but it does illustrate that in key traditions, alcoholic wine is normative.
5. Avoiding legalism: Making consumption of any alcohol a sin introduces a legalistic burden, which scripture warns against (Galatians 5:1,13). At the same time, ignoring scriptural warnings about excess opens the door to harm.
6. Health, recovery and conscience: Modern health studies show alcohol carries physical and social risks; the rise of non- and low-alcohol wines highlights this shift. For individuals with addiction struggles, for pregnant women, for designated drivers, the “safe” path may be abstinence or choosing non-alcoholic alternatives. Yet one must recognise that many so-called “non-alcoholic wines” still contain ~0.5 % ABV.
4. Conclusion: A Balanced, Faith-Informed View
In closing: drinking alcohol is not automatically a sin according to scripture — rather excess, intoxication, and harm to self or others are consistently condemned. The biblical record shows wine used in celebration (wedding at Cana), in sacrament (Communion), while also warning of the dangers of drunkenness. The modern proliferation of “non-alcoholic” wine complicates matters: yes, there are very low- or zero-alcohol alternatives, but many still carry trace amounts; furthermore, the cultural-theological meaning of “wine” differs from ancient to modern times.
So when someone says “drinking alcohol is still a sin”, you can respond: Not automatically. It’s more helpful to ask: “Is this drinking consistent with self-control, love for others, and the way of Christ?” The glass is not the issue — what matters is the heart, the habits, and the witness.
0 Comments