In recent days, a heated debate has erupted across Nigerian social media and music circles — not because of a new hit song, but over intellectual property and melody ownership. At the center of this controversy is renowned Nigerian folk musician Beautiful Nubia calls out BBO, Yinka Ayefele over ‘melody theft’ of his song ‘Seven Lifes’, who has publicly accused two gospel musicians of borrowing melodies from his classic work without permission or acknowledgement. His message — blunt, direct and uncompromising — is sparking fresh conversations about originality, creative ownership, and the professional standards of the Nigerian music industry.
The Accusations: What Happened?
On Thursday, veteran folk artist Beautiful Nubia, whose real name is Segun Akinlolu, took to his X (formerly Twitter) account to accuse gospel stars Yinka Ayefele and the emerging artist known as BBO of copyright infringement. Specifically, he claims that both artists lifted the core melody of his 1997 song Seven Lifes — a celebrated track in his rich catalogue — without his permission or proper credit.
According to Beautiful Nubia’s post, Yinka Ayefele’s 2012 gospel song My Faith in God (Igbagbo Ireti) and BBO’s 2026 release Amin both derive their main melodies from Seven Lifes. He lamented that this reflects a broader problem among Nigerian gospel musicians, questioning when they will begin to respect copyright laws and artistic originality.
As of now, neither Yinka Ayefele nor BBO has issued a public response to these claims.
Who Is Beautiful Nubia?
Beautiful Nubia is not a newcomer to Nigerian music. His real name is Olusegun Akinsete Akinlolu, and he has been active as a songwriter, performer, and bandleader since the late 1990s. He is widely recognized for his role in modern Nigerian folk and roots music and has released numerous albums, including Seven Lifes in 1997.
Despite his influence and longstanding career, he has not been shielded from the same industry challenges many musicians face — particularly around copyright protection, recognition, and financial rights. His recent outcry reflects growing frustration among creators who feel their original work is often used without authorization or acknowledgment.
Why This Matters: Copyright and the Creative Economy
At its core, the dispute raises deeper issues about how the Nigerian music industry treats intellectual property.
Copyright is a legal framework that gives creators exclusive rights to their artistic works — including songs, melodies, and lyrics — for a specified period of time. It ensures that when someone uses a piece of music, they must either get permission from the rights holder or compensate them for their use. This system is fundamental in mature music industries such as those in the United States, Europe, and parts of Asia, where litigation and licensing are common and widely respected.
However, in Nigeria — particularly within gospel music circles — enforcement and awareness of copyright laws have historically been uneven. Many artists, producers, and even broadcasters regularly use existing works without proper licensing or credit, often under the assumption that creative works shared within religious or community contexts are “free” to use.
This mindset creates a tension between music as a ministry and music as a livelihood. A recent academic discussion highlights that some gospel producers and churches see copyrighted music as a spiritual gift that should not be monetized, while others argue that creators still deserve legal and ethical compensation for their work.
The problem is not unique to gospel music. In the wider Nigerian entertainment world, several artists have publicly complained about melody copying or uncredited reuse of their original works. For example, singer Jaywon claimed that both gospel and Afrobeats acts were copying his 2012 song This Year without credit, reflecting broader frustrations with creative borrowing across genres.
Gospel Music and the Originality Debate
Gospel music in Nigeria is a vibrant and influential genre — one that blends traditional rhythms, spiritual lyrics, and popular music styles such as juju, highlife, afrobeat, and fuji. Artists like Yinka Ayefele have long been household names, celebrated for their contributions to Nigerian worship music and cultural life.
But the industry has also faced its share of controversies. Beyond the Beautiful Nubia case, there have been other public accusations of copyright disputes among gospel artists. In 2023, singer Funke accused Yinka Alaseyori of copying her work, reigniting debates about ownership and originality in gospel circles.
Meanwhile, international legal battles highlight that copyright is a global concern: world-famous gospel singer Sinach was reportedly sued by a producer claiming co-authorship of her hit Way Maker, although that case involved complex questions about contribution and rights.
These disputes point to a critical question: Can gospel music uphold artistic standards and respect for creative ownership while still maintaining its spiritual mission?
Why Gospel Artists Need to Uphold Copyright Respect
Some critics argue that gospel musicians often lag in originality because of certain cultural attitudes toward creativity, spirituality, and ownership. There’s a common belief among some artists that gospel music is a offering or ministry to God and therefore shouldn’t be subject to the same commercial scrutiny as secular music. While this perspective honors the spiritual intention of the genre, it can unintentionally foster environments where melodies and works are reused without consent or proper attribution.
But respect for copyright doesn’t undermine spirituality — it protects creativity. When artists respect each other’s work, it encourages originality, fair competition, and a healthier creative economy. Musicians who invest years into crafting melodies, arranging compositions, and building a signature sound deserve legal recognition and financial protection — regardless of genre.
Countries with structured music industries have robust copyright enforcement mechanisms. Without them, creators struggle to earn from their work, and markets become flooded with derivative material that dilutes cultural value and artistic integrity.
Lessons for the Nigerian Music Industry
The Beautiful Nubia controversy deserves landmark attention because it highlights a recurring pain point for many Nigerian artists: a lack of enforcement, awareness, and sometimes even respect for intellectual property rights.
For Nigeria’s music industry to mature — whether in gospel, afrobeat, highlife, or folk — several things must happen:
1. Education on copyright law — Musicians, producers, and industry professionals need training on copyright basics, licensing, royalties, and legal obligations.
2. Stronger enforcement — Regulatory bodies and music rights organizations should create practical systems to register and protect works.
3. Cultural shift — Artists and audiences alike must understand that respecting creative ownership fuels a healthier artistic ecosystem.
Conclusion: A Call for Respect and Professionalism
Beautiful Nubia’s public accusation isn’t just about melody theft. It’s about a larger call for professionalism, respect, and maturity in Nigerian music — especially in the gospel genre. When original creators feel unheard, uncredited, or unprotected, the industry suffers creatively and economically.
Respect for copyright should not be optional; it should be a cornerstone of artistic practice. Nigerian music has enormous global influence and potential. But that potential will only be fully realized when creators, regardless of genre, uphold the values of originality, ethical practice, and mutual respect.
When gospel artists begin to truly value both their spiritual message and their intellectual rights, the entire industry will benefit — artists, audiences, and culture alike.
0 Comments